Veganism solves nothing

I know, because I do it myself, that we can all overstate the miracle element of our faiths. More vegetables can be very good for us but  a vegetable only diet is only really even feasible if you are rich and pay extra for some animal products.
When someone's specific beliefs and high expectations are constantly in conflict with tested science, we observers and risk takers know it can be expected to be a time when those expectations are not only unhelpful, but actually misleading.
 For example, we won't, even as omnivore animals in ecosystems, make good use of available food sources if we don't eat things that are a result of decomposition.
We are born to live, like ruminants do to a greater extent than us , to use and rely on decomposition processes. 

    
A meat free diet is not the way to sustain the life of humans on the planet.  We rural folks, who work with animals may have to reject the pressure of the modern industrial treatment of animals when those processes do not take enough care of the animals. 
We have a long way to go with so many in the cities unaware of the unnecessary pressure industrial production and crude economics demands put on farmers and farmed animals . . Industry and shareholders still justify too much restriction of the freedom and lifestyle of animals ( including their custodians) . Its good  that  a new generation of counter economic buyers choose to buy open range eggs and pay more for things like milk so that margins in ecosystems are not squeezed, Let's all be part of that resistance movement and help improve the situation. 


I am trying to avoid a lengthy piece on why it is TOTALLY unsound to advocate veganism because there are just so many complex and sound reasons why we shouldn't all do it ,
Try it if you like, but please avoid this self righteous blinkeredness that it is what nature intended .Do your homework on nature http://designwithnature.blogspot.com
The principle reason a thinking person can't advocate it is that , like all these SIMPLE ,overly idealistic and blinkered city movements in history ( including Permaculture ) is it is nowhere near natural ( we are born omnivores and our mates are everywhere ) and its impossibly costly ( unless you want to pay someone to grow things for you or stay poor yourself ) and unsustainable.

Despite its attractiveness as an ideal, it is unsustainable because there is simply not enough low slope good soil and soil water combinations to keep it working for long in a rain fed way.
Most of us live in the Savannah where we have to accept production limits : rainfed hillslopes can produce annual crops but they can erode if we expose the soils too much and irrigation of most soils on the flats builds up salinity. Wheat oats and barley and rice are gifts that we can use safely ( resilience and capability qualifications), but only if we accept the proper place driven resilience limits in each and every patch of dirt 
As always with nature , things work best when the various composition and decomposition parts work together
A cow can cope with more milk  than one calf needs  and a good steak , like tough old grass,  is better,  if it and the connective tissue is breaking down on transit through us to the soil . 

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

When trees fall and lives are lost

Decomposition is our friend

What you can do to make Australia great.